FAFSA or the TOPS Online Application: What Each Covers for Louisiana Seniors

Louisiana high school senior comparing FAFSA and TOPS application options at a school college-planning workstation

File the FAFSA. It applies for TOPS and for everything else at once, while the TOPS Online Application applies only for TOPS and TOPS Tech. LOSFA’s own comparison is blunt: the TOPS Online Application “allows you to apply ONLY for TOPS/TOPS Tech,” and the FAFSA “allows you to apply for TOPS/TOPS Tech, other state aid, and all federal aid”.

Louisiana seniors now face this choice for the first time in years, because completing the FAFSA is no longer required to graduate. This article covers what each form unlocks, the one-way door between them that most families don’t know about, who the shorter form genuinely suits, and how to decide in about five minutes.

What Each Form Actually Unlocks

TOPS Online Application

FAFSA

TOPS and TOPS Tech

Yes

Yes

Federal Pell Grant

No

Yes

Federal student loans

No

Yes

Federal work-study

No

Yes

Louisiana GO Grant

No

Yes

M.J. Foster Promise Program

No

Required for it

Most campus institutional aid

No

Usually required

The TOPS Online Application does one job. The FAFSA does that job plus every other one. LOSFA spells out the overlap: “If you complete the FAFSA®, you do not have to fill out the TOPS Online Application to apply for TOPS.”

That’s the entire comparison. Everything else is about whether the extra doors the FAFSA opens are worth anything to your family, and the honest answer is that most families underestimate how many of them are.

The One-Way Door Nobody Mentions

LOSFA’s TOPS guidance contains a rule that turns this from a preference into a sequencing decision: “If you have already submitted a complete FAFSA, you will not be allowed to submit a TOPS On Line Application”.

The door only swings one way. Filing the FAFSA closes off the TOPS-only route, which costs you nothing, since the FAFSA already applied you for TOPS. Filing the TOPS Online Application first does not close off the FAFSA. So if you’re undecided, there’s no scenario where filing the FAFSA leaves you worse off on the TOPS side.

There is a second reason the FAFSA route is the safer default. Once you’ve filed it, you have a live application for federal and state aid you can correct and update. A student who filed only the TOPS application and then discovers in July that they need a federal loan has to start the FAFSA from scratch, with an FSA ID that takes one to three days to confirm with the Social Security Administration before they can even log in.

Who the TOPS Online Application Is Actually Built For

It exists for a specific situation, and LOSFA’s guidance describes it plainly: apply for TOPS through the FAFSA “unless you can demonstrate that you do not qualify for federal grant aid (Pell Grant).” The agency adds its own recommendation in the same breath: “We recommend that all students submit the FAFSA.”

So the shorter form is built for a family that is certain no federal need-based aid is coming and does not want to share income data to receive a merit award their student has already earned academically. That is a real and legitimate position. Privacy is a reasonable thing to weigh, and a family well above any need threshold is not wrong about the Pell math.

What makes it a narrower fit than it looks is that Pell eligibility is only one of the doors. The others stay shut regardless of income.

What You Give Up by Skipping the FAFSA

Four things, and only one of them is means-tested in the way families assume.

Federal student loans. Direct Unsubsidized Loans are not need-based. Income does not disqualify you. The only way to access them is a FAFSA on file. A family that expects to cover costs from savings and later hits an unexpected gap has no federal loan option without one.

The Louisiana GO Grant. It requires a FAFSA and Pell eligibility, and pays $300 to $3,000 a year.

Campus institutional aid. LOSFA notes that “many colleges also require the FAFSA® for the student to be considered for institutional aid.” Some Louisiana campuses tie merit scholarship consideration to a completed FAFSA by a priority date. LSU, for one, publishes a December 15 FAFSA priority deadline alongside its scholarship priority deadline for first-time freshmen.

The gap TOPS doesn’t cover. TOPS at the Opportunity, Performance, and Honors levels pays an award amount based on tuition as set for the 2016-17 academic year unless the Legislature increases it. Tuition has moved since then, and TOPS was never designed to cover fees, housing, books, or food. A student with TOPS and nothing else still has a bill.

The Deadlines Are the Same, the Consequences Are Not

Both routes run on the same TOPS clock. LOSFA sets the deadline for a full award at “July 1, or the next business day if July 1 falls on a weekend, following the one year anniversary of high school graduation,” with an award reduced by one semester if you’re 1 to 60 days late, by two semesters if you’re 61 to 120 days late, and no award at all beyond 120 days, with “no exceptions, waivers or appeals.”

LOSFA also sets a priority deadline of February 1 of senior year for FAFSA completion, so that TOPS processing runs on time and there’s room to fix errors. Supporting documents have their own cutoff: transcripts, residency affidavits, test scores, and anything else LOSFA requests must arrive “no later than January 15 immediately following the final deadline.”

Where the two routes diverge is what a missed deadline costs. Miss it on the TOPS-only path and you lose TOPS. Miss it on the FAFSA path and you’ve usually still got a FAFSA on file that keeps federal aid and GO Grant consideration alive, which is a materially softer landing.

What Changed With the Graduation Requirement

Louisiana was the first state in the country to require FAFSA completion for high school graduation, starting with the class of 2018. The Board of Elementary and Secondary Education rescinded that policy, and LOSFA now states plainly that “completing the FAFSA® form is no longer a requirement for high school graduation in Louisiana.”

The state kept the incentive while removing the mandate. LOSFA still lists the reasons to file: access to Pell, federal loans, and work-study; state aid including the GO Grant; institutional aid at many colleges; and the observation that “students leave millions of dollars in Pell Grant funding on the table each year when they don’t complete the FAFSA®.”

Nationally the trend is the opposite direction. The high school class of 2026 set a record 59.1% FAFSA completion rate through late June. The removal of the requirement means Louisiana families now have to opt in deliberately rather than being carried along by a graduation checklist.

How to Decide in Five Minutes

Answer four questions honestly.

Will your student possibly borrow a federal loan at any point in four years, including for a study-abroad term, a fifth year, or an emergency? If yes, file the FAFSA. Loans are not income-restricted, so this question alone settles it for most families.

Is there any chance of Pell eligibility? Run the Federal Student Aid Estimator before assuming no. The formula considers factors beyond income, and family size and the number of students in college move the result more than people expect.

Does any college on your list require the FAFSA for institutional scholarship consideration? Check each school’s financial aid page rather than assuming, and note the priority date while you’re there.

Are you willing to redo the FSA ID process and the full form in July if circumstances change? If not, file now.

If all four answers point to the FAFSA, file it and skip the TOPS Online Application entirely. If your family is certain on all four counts and privacy is the deciding factor, the TOPS Online Application does the job it was built for, and you keep the option to file a FAFSA later.

Which Form Should Louisiana Seniors Use to Apply for TOPS?

  • FAFSA: applies for TOPS, Pell, federal loans, work-study, GO Grant, and most campus aid
  • TOPS Online Application: applies for TOPS and TOPS Tech only
  • Filing the FAFSA means you do not need the TOPS application
  • Once a complete FAFSA is filed, the TOPS Online Application is no longer available

File the Form That Keeps Every Door Open

The TOPS Online Application is a valid choice for a narrow set of families, and LOSFA built it for exactly that group. For everyone else, the FAFSA does the same TOPS job and several more, and it takes about ten minutes once the FSA ID exists and the prior-prior year tax return is on the table. Set up both FSA IDs now, file the FAFSA in the first week it opens, and confirm the TOPS status in your LOSFA Student Hub once processing begins in June. That sequence gets you the merit award you were going to get anyway, plus everything the shorter form would have left on the table.

References

Share the Post:

Related Posts